File a Claim

To File a Claim After Hours:  (If Assistance is needed right away)

Agency Insurance Company (AIC):          1-800-841-5241  (available from 8:30A – 5P)


Allegheny Insurance/Conemaugh Valley Insurance:          1-877-346-0300 (Emergency Claims Line)


American Collectors:          1-800-360-2277 (M-F 8:30A – 7P) (Sat & Sun 9A-5P)


Dairyland Insurance:          1-800-334-0090 (24hr)


Farmers and Mechanics:          1-855-725-5642  (24hr)


Foremost Insurance:          1-800-527-3907  (24hr)


Goodville Mutual Casualty Insurance:          1-877-445-5780  (24hr)


Hagerty Insurance Company:          1-800-922-4050 (M-F 8A-8P) (Sat 8:30A-4:30P)(Sun 12p-4P)


Livingston Mutual Insurance Company:          1-855-725-5642  (24hr)


Mutual Benefit Insurance Company:          1-800-290-6361  (24hr)


Progressive Insurance:          1-800-274-4499  (24hr)


Reamstown Mutual Insurance Company:          1-717-336-6962  (24hr)


Universal Property Insurance Company:          1-800-425-9113  (24hr)


Westfield Insurance Company:          1-866-937-2663  (24hr)


Westfield Glass Claims can be submitted online at:           Westfield Glass Claims Only